Frequently Asked Questions

As you can see in the picture on the left all the cookie cutters in a set are made from one mold. So when we make a set we have an equal number of cutters. If we were to sell one cutter individually probability is that it would run out before the rest. So it would be a never-ending cycle of too many Stars and not enough Santa’s.

Gramma’s Cutters stock is only in opaque red plastic. The transparent cookie cutters you are speaking of were some of Aunt Chick’s™ first to go on the market. Unfortunately, the plastic was not very strong and tended to crack and break more easily.

We are not looking to purchase any Aunt Chick’s Cookie Cuttersbut if you have anything different to share (unusual colors or decorating techniques) we would love pictures. However, if you are looking to sell your Aunt Chick’s cookie cutters I would recommend eBay!

I have seen the flower cookie cutters made in yellow, pink, and white plastics. The cowboy and angel cutters were made out of pink marbled plastic. I have also heard of green plastic but haven’t seen any examples. I think these plastics were used in smaller runs though so they are collector items.

I have been gifted 2 full Aunt Chick’s™ Pastry Kits by wonderful customers who were generous enough to share. We do offer the shell-piercer, starburst, and cherry/ leaf cutters, and have done our best to find a Pastry Cloth that is as good as the original but it is not the original Pastry Cloth because Aunt Chick actually made these by hand. Cherish the ones you have. If you are interested in the pie cutters we offer them in our store as Aunt Chick’s Pastry Cutters!

She sold the HRM Gingerboy cutter which you can find on many other websites. She never had a cutter that she designed though. But today we offer our Aunt Chick’s Gingerbread Man in our American Traditions Cookie Cutter Set.

Aunt Chick stopped offering these cookie cutters after her mold was stolen/confiscated (depends on who you ask). However Gramma’s Cutters was able to purchase original Aunt Chick’s Angel and Cowboy cookie cutters, then have them laser scanned and a mold made from the originals. A long process but a perfect reproduction!

Good question! These cutters were hard to come by because she didn’t offer them for very long. As Aunt Chick put it “A very bad man stole the mold that had the cowboy and angel designs in it.” This was in the 1960s, if you find the originals they are made out of pink marble plastic. Today they are offered in our Jolly Days Set!

We were able to acquire the original Pilgrim design that Aunt Chick came up with for her cookie-cutter but she never actually made it. It looked more like a witch is probably why she didn’t do it – we had customers vote on designs when we made our Pilgrim Cookie Cutter in our American Traditions Set but our new design won out.

Gramma’s Cutters started as a way to help families continue their baking holiday traditions. However, we have received such a great response from customers that we added Aunt Chick’s American Traditions Cookie Cutter Set recently and we hope to continue adding more in the next few years.

I cannot find any information of Aunt Chick offering a Nativity set. It could possibly have been an HRM cookie cutter set (which we do not offer). However, if you have a Nativity Set you believe to be Aunt Chick’s™ please send me a picture so I can post it on the website.

The Four McB’s are Nettie McBirneys four children who inherited the Aunt Chick’s™ Company when Ms. McBirney retired. They went on to produce the cookie cutters and pastry sets for quite a few more years before they retired also.

Comments (8)

  1. Judy Walburn

    I am looking for the red opaque snowman. Mine is broken and I use him every Christmas as my mom did. Now my daughter is using the set.

    June 8, 2021 at 2:13 pm Reply
  2. Steve Peters

    My mother had a Christmas set from the ’40s in transparent red plastic. I thought it also had a reindeer and sleigh. Is this correct?

    June 8, 2021 at 2:31 pm Reply
  3. priscilla smith

    Are all cookie cutters new? My grandson has gluten allergy and needs them new.

    June 8, 2021 at 4:41 pm Reply
  4. Cheryl Meeker

    I have my mothers cutters, 5 Christmas and a bunny, clown, and pumpkin. I also have the paper with the recipe all in excellent condition. My daughter is an artist and I have ask her if she would like them. I loved theses cookies as a child, and I am 72

    June 8, 2021 at 4:42 pm Reply
  5. Kelly

    I grew up with Aunt Chick’s Xmas Set and my children did too. Now my grandchildren look forward to them each Xmas … I also bought my daughters each a set. I have my moms set still in the box with instructions 😁😁

    June 8, 2021 at 4:43 pm Reply
  6. Cindy Bower

    I was thrilled to find these as a wedding gift so that our family can carry on a tradition started by my grandmother for her children and then all of us.

    June 8, 2021 at 4:44 pm Reply
  7. Janice

    Any chance of finding an original box (even in poor condition) or a replica of one? I’m referencing the one in the top photo of this Q & A section.

    June 8, 2021 at 4:44 pm Reply
  8. Joan Rosolowsky

    Hi Janice. I know you posted this a year ago but I check back on this site from time to time. Were you interested in pictures of original boxes or obtaining one? I have multiple original boxes but at present, I won’t part with them. My mother-in-law was an avid user of these cutters in the forties and fifties….and beyond. I have some of the original cutters that were manufactured in translucent red plastic. Once my husband’s mom showed them to me I immediately started to get creative with them and have never missed a season in the 41 years we are married. The list of recipients each year is still growing. I contacted the McBirney brothers, Aunt Chick’s sons in the seventies and so did my mom. I still have some of their handwritten correspondence. When my boys were little and I made the cookies for their classmates all the moms wanted the recipes and purchasing info. The boxes I have are not in mint condition. Some flaps are missing. It’s interesting to see the gradual changes in the address and text details from my mother-in-law’s boxes to the ones I purchased in the seventies.

    June 8, 2021 at 4:46 pm Reply
Leave your thought here